PROCEEDINGS OF THE
STATE OF
) SS
Proceedings of the regular meeting of the Knox County Board, held at the
Knox County Courthouse,
The meeting was called to order by Chairman Janet Occhi and upon roll
call the following members reported present:
District 1
Caroline Porter
District 2
Paul Stewart
District 3
Janet Occhi
District
4 George Knapp
District
5 Gerald Link
District
1 Allen Pickrel
District
2 Greg Bacon
District
3 Paul Hevland
District
4 Wayne Saline
District
5 Ricardo
Sandoval
District
1 Linda Roberts
District
2 Dana
Shallenberger
District
3 Dale Parsons
District
4
District 5
Stephen Johnson
Also
present was Scott Erickson,
Chairman Occhi led the Members in the pledge to the flag. Rev. Lee
Johnson, Pastor of
Member Pickrel asked for a moment of silence for the Darrell Hughes
family.
Chairman
Occhi asked for additions to the agenda. Member Johnson asked for an addition to
the agenda to discuss the conflict of interest policy. Chairman Occhi stated
that would be item 12 A. Member Saline asked that item 25 referring to the
approval of a road center line agreement for GIS data be removed from the agenda
as the paperwork was not in. Chairman Occhi asked that agenda item 23 regarding
the insurance for doctors at the Nursing Home be moved up before agenda item 4.
Chairman
Occhi asked for public comment. Rob Benedict asked about the sale of acreage at
the Nursing Home. Three months ago, the Board voted to sell some of this
farmland. He asked if a procedure had been set in place or a committee
appointed. As spring approaches, farmers need to know how to proceed.
Chairman
Occhi presented for approval the following items of the consent agenda: 1)
minutes of the Board Meeting and closed Board Meeting held January 11, 2006, 2)
claims by Members for per diem and mileage for the meeting of January 25, 2006,
and 3) sales tax and various taxes for the month of October 2005 in the amounts
of $78,668.63 and $21,914.43 and public safety tax in the amount of $70,782.22.
Motion was made by Member Parsons and seconded by Member Johnson to approve
these items. Roll call vote is recorded as follows: Ayes—Porter, Stewart,
Occhi, Knapp, Link, Pickrel, Bacon, Hevland, Saline, Sandoval, Roberts,
Shallenberger, Parsons, Mannhardt, and Johnson—(15). Noes—(0). Motion
carried.
Marianne
Wiesen presented for discussion/approval the matter of insurance for the doctor
at the Nursing Home. Motion was made by Member Porter and seconded by Member
Parsons to provide liability insurance for the doctor who serves as medical
director for an estimated annual cost of $2,500. Member Saline expressed concern
that the Board should not establish a policy to provide insurance for others. It
would be a better decision to increase the stipend to allow the doctor to
purchase his own insurance. Member Bacon expressed his opinion that the doctor
should provide his own insurance. Roll call vote is recorded as follows:
Ayes—Porter, Stewart, Occhi, Knapp, Link, Pickrel, Hevland, Sandoval, Roberts,
Shallenberger, Parsons, Mannhardt, and Johnson—(13). Noes—Bacon, and
Saline—(2). Motion carried.
Chris
Wood introduced Barb Knox, from IDOT, who presented a visual presentation
regarding the road center line agreement. She spoke of the transportation
coalition which encourages local efforts between State, city, and local agencies
to share road center line data. By the terms of this two year agreement there
would be no fee involved. This information could only be shared with others
within the County. This data could not be sold. It will also help with tourism
and economic development.
Chairman
Occhi requested the following Members be appointed to the ad hoc committee for
building and construction: Member Link, Member Sandoval, Member Bacon, Member
Saline, and Member Occhi. Motion was made by Member Parsons and seconded by
Member Stewart to approve these appointments. Roll call vote is recorded as
follows: Ayes—Porter, Stewart, Occhi, Knapp, Link, Pickrel, Bacon, Hevland,
Roberts, Shallenberger, Parsons, Mannhardt, and Johnson—(13). Noes—(0).
Pass—Saline, and Sandoval—(2). Motion carried.
Chairman
Occhi requested the following Members be appointed to the ad hoc committee for
GIS fees: Member Porter, Member Hevland, and Member Roberts. Motion was made by
Member Saline and seconded by Member Pickrel to approve these appointments. Roll
call vote is recorded as follows: Ayes—Porter, Stewart, Occhi, Knapp, Link,
Pickrel, Bacon, Saline, Sandoval, Roberts, Shallenberger, Parsons, Mannhardt,
and Johnson—(14). Noes—(0). Pass—Hevland—(1). Motion carried.
Chairman
Occhi requested that Member Porter be appointed to the GIS steering committee.
Motion was made by Member Saline and seconded by Member Pickrel to approve this
appointment. Roll call vote is recorded as follows: Ayes—Porter, Stewart,
Occhi, Knapp, Link, Pickrel, Bacon, Hevland, Saline, Sandoval, Roberts,
Shallenberger, Parsons, Mannhardt, and Johnson—(15). Noes—(0). Motion
carried.
Motion
was made by Member Parsons and seconded by Member Stewart to approve the union
contract with AFSCME Local 3217, courthouse employees. Roll call vote is
recorded as follows: Ayes—Porter, Stewart, Occhi, Pickrel, Bacon, Hevland,
Saline, Sandoval, Roberts, Shallenberger, Parsons, and Mannhardt—(12). Noes—Knapp,
and Link—(2). Pass—Johnson—(1). Motion carried.
Chairman
Occhi presented for approval resolutions for deeds of conveyance for parcel
numbers 1222427004, 1223327008, 1333382025, 9913176007, and 9915379008. Motion
to approve this measure was made by Member Parsons and seconded by Member
Roberts. Roll call vote is recorded as follows: Ayes—Porter, Stewart, Occhi,
Knapp, Link, Pickrel, Bacon, Hevland, Saline, Sandoval, Roberts, Shallenberger,
Parsons, Mannhardt, and Johnson—(15). Noes—(0). Motion carried.
Chairman
Occhi presented for discussion/approval a letter of engagement with Carpentier,
Mitchell, Goddard & Company LLC for the County audit. A representative from
the company, Jim Taylor, stated that the company was seeking clarification
whether the County wanted a two or four year contract. It was their original
understanding that the County wanted a four year contract. Yet when the minutes
were reviewed it seemed to indicate a two year contract was approved. One of the
advantages of a four year contract would be that the upfront costs of that first
year are more evenly divided over the remaining years. Motion was made by Member
Saline and seconded by Member Bacon to approve the four year contract with this
company. Roll call vote is recorded as follows: Ayes—Porter, Stewart, Occhi,
Knapp, Link, Pickrel, Bacon, Hevland, Saline, Sandoval, Roberts, Shallenberger,
Parsons, Mannhardt, and Johnson—(15). Noes—(0). Motion carried.
Member
Parsons presented a report from the ad hoc committee for the
Treasurer
Robin Davis presented the revenue and expense countywide report for December
2005. She reminded Members this report had been inserted in the packets. She
also passed out a handout which was a brief guideline which shows where expenses
and revenues should be each month. Some of these figures were one time only
expenses. Some adjustments need to be made in appropriation lines and
appropriation numbers. These adjustments will be included in the January report.
Motion
was made by Member Parsons and seconded by Member Bacon to approve the
resolution on increasing the minimum pricing for auction sales by delinquent tax
agents. Treasurer Robin Davis reminded Members that this resolution would
increase the minimum bid to $600. Voice vote is recorded as follows:
Ayes—(15). Noes—(0). Motion carried.
Member Johnson addressed the conflict of interest policy that was
approved at the previous meeting. He stated that when he began his term as Board
Member there were some questions regarding a possible conflict of interest
concerning his wife. The Attorney General had issued an opinion. However, some
Members of the Board do not agree with this opinion. This conflict of interest
resolution was based on a blatant lie. 1) This resolution was not prepared by
attorney Bruce Beal. 2) There is no case law to support this resolution. 3) This
resolution is not in place in place in
Member Saline stated that in the history of the Board there were times
when either county employees or Board Members have resigned to avoid a possible
conflict of interest.
State’s Attorney, Paul Mangieri responded that by virtue of his
position, he is the County’s legal authority. He and the Attorney General
share the same opinion that there is no conflict of interest with this Board
Member and the fact that his wife is an employee of the County. Similarly, in
that same opinion Member Shallenberger’s position was also questioned. At that
time she worked part time in the coroner’s office. The ruling regarding her
was that as long as she did not receive wages to exceed a specific dollar
amount, there was not a conflict of interest. Mr. Mangieri had written a letter
to the Attorney General asking for his opinion regarding the validity of this
conflict of interest policy. Mr. Mangieri thinks this policy is problematic for
the Board to determine which individual might have a conflict of interest. He
has concerns that this policy may violate a Member’s constitutional rights.
Member Porter reiterated her reasons why Member Johnson does have a
conflict of interest. She stated that she doesn’t care what the Attorney
General’s opinion is; this does represent a conflict of interest on this
Board.
Member Johnson responded that his wages have never exceeded the legal
monetary limits. Therefore, Member Porter’s comments are out of line. No one
is going to stop him for talking about what goes on in this County.
John Kennedy presented the animal control business report. He stated that
he is working with DNR to get some help to deal with the County’s coyotes.
Additionally a couple of people from the animal control department are starting
to work on this problem. These coyotes are becoming quite a problem for
livestock.
John
Kennedy presented for approval the resolution for fess increase and collection
of fees. This resolution was prepared by Mr. Mangieri. The $10 differential
annual fee that was originally omitted has been added. Motion was made by Member
Johnson and seconded by Member Sandoval to approve this amended resolution. Roll
call vote is recorded as follows: Ayes—Porter, Stewart, Occhi, Knapp, Link,
Pickrel, Bacon, Hevland, Saline, Sandoval, Roberts, Shallenberger, Parsons,
Mannhardt, and Johnson—(15). Noes—(0). Motion carried.
Rod
Cleair presented the Mary Davis Home business report. For the month of December,
they billed out approximately $72,000 for out of County care. They averaged 24
clients per day, with 10.5 clients from the County. In December, they did
receive two checks from the State and another two checks this month. Today there
were 34 clients and 8 of those from the County.
Rod
Cleair presented for approval the bid from Pratt Audio Visual & Video
Corporation for the security system at the Mary Davis Home. He reported that
this was the only bid that was received. This bid which includes an itemized
list was handed out to the Members. Motion was made by Member Sandoval and
seconded by Member Link to accept this bid in the amount of $151,976.00. Roll
call vote is recorded as follows: Ayes—Porter, Stewart, Occhi, Knapp, Link,
Bacon, Hevland, Saline, Sandoval, Roberts, Shallenberger, Parsons, Mannhardt,
and Johnson—(14). Noes—Pickrel—(1). Motion carried. Rod Cleair stated that
once they get started, the work was expected to take about five weeks.
Joyce
Skinner presented the assessor’s report business report. Regarding the
resolutions for deeds of conveyance, she instructed the Board that the first two
digits of the number refer to the township, the middle numbers refer to the
section, the next digits refer to the quadrant such as the SE corner, and the
last four digits are the parcel number.
She
reported that she had received the multiplier from the State and it is a “1”
again. They will pay half of her salary for another year. The Board of Review
Hearings have been completed. Today was the State hearing for the Raritan Bank
in Abingdon.
Debbie
Canier presented a zoning report. They have been meeting with neighboring
counties to draft a wind farm ordinance.
Larry
Larson presented the landfill business report. The compactor is put back
together and is again operational. It was under warranty.
Duane
Ratermann presented the highway business report. They did excavate the
courthouse parking lot and will continue to monitor it for any changes.
There
has been some discussion with the City of
Marianne
Wiesen presented the Nursing Home business report. They had received the plans
from the sprinkler company and those plans have been sent to
Marianne
Wiesen presented for approval to bid and bring back for a dishwasher for the
Nursing Home. Motion was made by Member Pickrel and seconded by Member Mannhardt
to approve this item. Voice vote is recorded as follows: Ayes—(15). Noes—(0).
Motion carried.
Motion
was made by Member Parsons and seconded by Member Johnson to approve the union
contract for the Nursing Home. Roll call vote is recorded as follows:
Ayes—Porter, Stewart, Occhi, Knapp, Link, Pickrel, Bacon, Hevland, Saline,
Sandoval, Roberts, Shallenberger, Parsons, Mannhardt, and Johnson—(15). Noes—(0).
Motion carried.
Ms.
Wiesen thanked everyone who had a part in these negotiations.
Chris
Wood presented the GIS business report. He had finished his part of the work on
the land use layer. He will be sending that off to Sidwell and then have them do
the air check. Worst case scenario is that it would take 4-6 weeks to get that
information back.
In
the previous meeting, Member Porter had asked about the accuracy of the parcels.
In conversations with the assessor’s office, Mr. Wood was told that 90-95% of
the over 3,000 parcels are accurate. Often the legal descriptions that the
office receives are not totally accurate. By that time this information has
already been recorded in the recorder’s office. Then it is difficult to get
this information corrected. Ms. Gray, from the assessor’s office, has asked
that the Board set up a procedure to simplify this correction process. She
reports that sometimes these things sit on her desk for up to a year before she
can get a correction. Possibly things need to go to her before they are
recorded.
Mr.
Wood had not yet received the center line agreement. This should be in the next
packet. The office furniture was expected to arrive January 25.
Motion
was made by Member Parsons and seconded by Member Roberts to approve claims
against
STATEMENTS OF
GENERAL CONCERN
None of the Members had any comments at this time.
Chairman Occhi announced that the next regular meeting will be held
Motion was made by Member Sandoval and seconded by Member Johnson to
adjourn. Voice vote is recorded as follows: Ayes—(15). Noes—(0). Motion
carried. Meeting was adjourned at